Yelp has become quite the platform for not only reviewing restaurants, hotels, stores and everything in between, but also architecture and public spaces. Who knew?
Curious to see what people had to say about some of Boston’s most beautiful “ugly” buildings, I conducted a search on Yelp.
It turns out, people love the Christian Science Monitor Complex in Boston, a complex with an excellent collection of concrete buildings from around the 1970’s, but hate Boston City Hall. Who knew? Bostonians love to hate it, while those reviewers from other states like it.
Did you know that in 1976, on a national survey conducted by the American Institute of Architects and taken by architects, critics and historians in the United States, Boston City Hall was voted as one of the ten greatest works in American architectural history? I have been saying that for years, but read it from our very own architecture critic Robert Campbell.
I think Boston City Hall is one of the most beautiful buildings in the City of Boston. Let’s agree to disagree.
Yelp Reviews of City Hall:
Jeremy G. from Humble, TX – writes “THIS is the building Le Corbusier **WISHED** he had designed.”
Beans B. from Brighton, MA: “From the wind-swept brick wasteland outside to the ridiculously narrow and uncomfortable spectator seats in the city council chamber to the lack of sufficient restrooms this building is a disaster.”
Alexandra S. from Hingham, MA: “There’s no avoiding the area for me since I walk through Boston City Hall plaza twice a day during the week. Ultimately, the sad reality is that no matter how much I’ve looked for something to appreciate, I don’t like this building.
I’ll even go a step further and say that there is in fact nothing redeeming at all about Boston CIty Hall and the red brick environs. I finally just have to admit to myself that this is just one ugly and off-putting building and plaza.”
Sebastian Y. from Boston, MA: “A monstrosity apparently designed by angry communists, which would look more at home on the outskirts of Moscow or Minsk.”
Hans W. from Brooklyn, NY writes: “City Hall is a badass spaceship space palace, and it’s sitting downtown because in 1962 someone had an original idea and someone else took a chance on it. And that’s what life’s all about.”-
K G. from Boston, MA: “I don’t despise the building itself as much as many people seem to. I have not seen another building like it, so you can call it unique at least.”
Jack M. from Boston, MA: “As a friend of mine once said, “Boston City Hall is the ugliest piece of architecture on the planet”.
Dan B. from Newton, MA: “The Boston City Hall looks like a good design for a maximum security prison in the Soviet Union. Except even the Soviets would never have come up with the giant concrete stilts, which causes the building’s underside to loom over congress street and the unfortunate security guards who work there.”
Courtney P. from Boston, MA: “This building is just ugly. With architecture being one of my favorite parts of Boston, it’s so disappointing that this building is City Hall. Please consider building something else!”
What do you think of Boston City Hall? Let’s hear your thoughts.